Defending Android
I like Android — that’s not a big secret. Currently I own T-Mobile G1 and I hope to get Nexus One (or Two?) some time soon. And I would also never ever even consider buying an iPhone. Why? Because I like to do things my way and not the way Steve tells me to.
I was shocked, amazed, and angered while listening to the latest episode of TWig. Two of the hosts — Leo Laporte and Gina Trapani — have Nexus One, and Jeff Jarvis is an Apple fanboy. Usually both Leo and Gina do a pretty good job explaining things to clueless Jarvis, but in this last episode he was blabbering nonsense and other hosts were just eating it up.
Maybe they just didn’t want to start pointless discussion (arguing to Apple fanboy is like talking to a wall), I don’t know, but let me explain couple things Jeff got wrong.
1. “Google app on iPhone is better than on Android”
First of all, Android has Google Apps, not a single Google app, which my understanding is what iPhone has. So instead of launching an app to fire-up other apps, you have separate applications: Gmail, Maps, News, Voice Search, etc.
2. “It’s hard to get to news”
Well, hello, that was the big thing with the so called Genie Widget, that displays weather, news, and other useful info. Freakin’ iPhone doesn’t even have widgets! And if you don’t want a widget, because you’re saving screen space or are concerned about battery life, just use the app. It’s called… (surprise surprise) News!
Maybe the problem is that Mr Jarvis doesn’t know how to get into menu as it’s not like iPhone where the whole damn phone is one big menu. It wouldn’t surprise me as he didn’t know what notifications are for and how to turn them off.
There are other things Jeff gets terribly wrong, but I can’t stand it any more, so I just fast forward the parts where he talks about Nexus One. I’d be sympathetic if he admited that he does not know how to do stuff and asked for help, but he keeps telling how it’s much easier on the iPhone and so on. Of course it’s easier when you have used it for a while. Stop “thinking” like Steve told you to and start thinking for yourself!
I think both iPhone and Nexus One are great phones and they have their own specific markets. Android is for people who like experimenting, discovering, and figuring things themselves. Whereas iPhone is for “busy” (read: lazy) people who can’t be arsed to do anything more than learn how to use a single button.